Common VAT Audit Findings and How to Avoid Them

VAT audits by the Federal Tax Authority (FTA) can result in substantial penalties if errors are discovered. Based on hundreds of VAT audits we've conducted and supported, we've identified the most common findings and how to prevent them.

Understanding these common issues allows you to proactively address them before an FTA audit.

Understanding FTA VAT Audits

The FTA conducts VAT audits to verify compliance with Federal Decree-Law No. 8 of 2017 on VAT. Audits can be:

Risk-Based: Triggered by anomalies in returns, industry patterns, or specific risk indicators Random: Selected statistically from VAT-registered businesses Specific: Following complaints, refund claims, or related investigations

Audit Timeline: FTA typically requests 3-5 years of records and conducts audits over 4-12 weeks depending on business size.

Finding #1: Incorrect Input Tax Recovery

The Issue: Claiming input VAT on expenses that don't qualify, or recovering VAT at incorrect rates.

Common Scenarios:

Personal Expenses Claimed:

• Directors using company cards for personal purchases
• Mixed business/personal use (car leases, phones) without proper allocation
• Entertainment expenses not clearly business-related

Exempt Supply Inputs:

• Claiming input VAT on expenses related to exempt supplies (residential property, some financial services)
• Not properly attributing shared expenses between standard-rated and exempt supplies

Zero-Rated Misapplication:

• Treating exports as standard-rated
• Not obtaining proper export documentation
• Incorrect treatment of international services

Penalties:

• VAT assessment: Underpaid VAT plus 5% penalty per month (capped at original tax amount)
• Serious cases: Up to 50% additional penalty for deliberate errors

How to Avoid:

1. Implement expense approval requiring business purpose documentation
2. Create allocation methodology for mixed-use assets (personal/business and standard/exempt)
3. Train staff on what qualifies for input tax recovery
4. Review input tax claims monthly, not just at return filing
5. Maintain clear policies on entertainment and business-related expenses

Example: A trading company claimed AED 45,000 input VAT on luxury vehicle purchases for directors. FTA audit determined personal use was 60% based on mileage logs, resulting in AED 27,000 disallowed input tax plus penalties of AED 8,100 (30%).

Finding #2: Documentation and Record-Keeping Deficiencies

The Issue: Inability to provide required supporting documentation during audit or maintaining inadequate records.

Common Documentation Problems:

Tax Invoice Issues:

• Missing or incorrect TRN (Tax Registration Number)
• Invoices lacking required information (date, description, VAT amount)
• Handwritten invoices without proper authorization
• Credit notes not properly documented

Missing Source Documents:

• Lost supplier invoices
• Unclear scanning/filing systems
• Email confirmations instead of proper tax invoices
• Purchase orders without corresponding invoices

Retention Failures:

• Records not maintained for required 5 years
• Digital records inaccessible due to system changes
• Paper records damaged or incomplete

Penalties:

• AED 10,000 fine for failure to maintain records
• AED 5,000 fine per tax invoice not provided
• Assessment of tax based on best judgment if records inadequate

How to Avoid:

1. Implement digital document management with backup systems
2. Create tax invoice checklist template and train staff
3. Conduct quarterly invoice compliance reviews
4. Establish clear record retention policy with secure storage
5. Use OCR/automated systems to flag incomplete invoices at receipt

Our Record-Keeping Checklist:

• All invoices contain: Supplier name, TRN, date, description, amounts, VAT breakdown
• Documents stored electronically with backup
• Organized by period/category for easy retrieval
• Clear audit trail from source document to VAT return
• Retention schedule ensuring 5+ year availability

Finding #3: Timing Differences (Tax Point Errors)

The Issue: Reporting VAT in the wrong tax period due to misunderstanding tax point rules.

Common Scenarios:

Cash Basis vs. Accrual:

• Companies on cash basis reporting VAT on invoice date instead of payment date
• Accrual basis companies not recognizing VAT when invoice issued (even if unpaid)

Advance Payments:

• Not accounting for VAT when deposit/advance received
• Waiting until final invoice to report VAT on advances

Continuous Supply Contracts:

• Not properly accounting for VAT on ongoing services
• Incorrect treatment of retainage/holdback amounts

Deemed Supply:

• Failing to account for VAT on deemed supplies (goods taken for personal use, business gifts over AED 500)

Penalties:

• Late payment penalties: 2% immediately, 4% if 7+ days late, then 1% per day (maximum 300%)
• Even if total VAT is correct across periods, penalties apply for wrong timing

How to Avoid:

1. Clearly understand your tax point election (cash vs. accrual basis)
2. Create month-end cutoff procedures to capture all tax points
3. Implement controls for advance payments and deposits
4. Review deemed supply transactions quarterly
5. Set VAT return calendar with buffer time for review

Example: Construction company on accrual basis issued AED 1.05M invoice (including VAT) on March 28, but reported it in April return because payment wasn't received until April 10. FTA assessed late payment penalty of AED 6,300 (6% on AED 50,000 VAT) even though total VAT paid was correct.

Finding #4: Place of Supply Errors

The Issue: Incorrect determination of where supply occurs, leading to wrong VAT treatment.

Common Scenarios:

Services to Non-GCC:

• Treating services to international clients as standard-rated instead of outside scope
• Not verifying recipient location adequately
• Incorrect treatment of online/digital services

Goods Movement:

• Exports not properly documented (no customs declarations)
• Imports not accounting for reverse charge VAT
• Goods moved between GCC states without proper treatment

Mixed Supplies:

• Part of service delivered in UAE, part internationally
• Not properly allocating based on where benefit received

Penalties:

• Over-declared VAT: No refund if error not corrected timely
• Under-declared VAT: Assessment plus penalties

How to Avoid:

1. Implement customer location verification (address, delivery location, IP address for digital)
2. Train sales team on VAT implications of international transactions
3. Create checklist for export documentation (customs forms, proof of export)
4. Review place of supply monthly for all international transactions
5. Maintain evidence of where services consumed/goods delivered

Finding #5: Exemption and Zero-Rating Misapplication

The Issue: Incorrectly applying VAT exemptions or zero-rating when supplies should be standard-rated, or vice versa.

Common Scenarios:

Residential vs. Commercial Property:

• Treating commercial property sales as exempt (only residential first sale is exempt)
• Bare land sales incorrectly zero-rated
• Serviced apartments treated as residential when actually commercial

Financial Services:

• Over-broad interpretation of financial services exemption
• Debt collection, financial advice incorrectly claimed as exempt

Education and Healthcare:

• Private tutoring claimed as exempt educational services
• Alternative medicine services claimed under healthcare exemption
• Educational materials sold separately from tuition

International Transport:

• Domestic leg of international journey zero-rated incorrectly
• Supporting services to transport not qualifying

Penalties:

• Output VAT underpaid: Tax assessment plus 5-50% penalties
• Incorrect zero-rating: Lost input tax recovery in some cases

How to Avoid:

1. Maintain detailed criteria for each exemption/zero-rating category
2. Review marginal cases with tax advisor before applying exemption
3. Document basis for exemption/zero-rating decisions
4. Annual review of all exempt/zero-rated supplies to ensure continued qualification
5. When in doubt, apply standard rating and seek FTA clarification

Example: Healthcare provider offered both regulated medical services (exempt) and wellness spa services (standard-rated). Failed to separate, treating all as exempt. FTA audit assessed AED 156,000 VAT on wellness services plus AED 46,800 penalty.

Finding #6: Voluntary Disclosure Issues

The Issue: Discovering errors but failing to correct them through voluntary disclosure, or making inadequate disclosures.

Common Problems:

Delayed Disclosure:

• Discovering errors but waiting months before notifying FTA
• Making disclosure only after receiving audit notification (no longer "voluntary")

Incomplete Disclosure:

• Disclosing only what you think FTA might find
• Not conducting comprehensive review when one error discovered

Inadequate Documentation:

• Voluntary disclosure without clear explanation of error, periods affected, and correction methodology

Benefits of Proper Voluntary Disclosure:

• Penalty reduction from 50% to 5% for qualifying disclosures
• Demonstrates good faith and compliance culture
• Potentially avoids full audit if disclosure is comprehensive

How to Handle Discovered Errors:

1. Immediate Review: When error found, conduct comprehensive review of same type of transaction across all open periods
2. Quantify Impact: Calculate exact VAT impact per period
3. Document Thoroughly: Prepare explanation of error, root cause, correction methodology
4. Prompt Disclosure: File voluntary disclosure within 20 business days of discovery
5. Corrective Measures: Implement controls to prevent recurrence and document them

Finding #7: Refund Claim Abuse

The Issue: Overclaiming VAT refunds through inflated input tax, fictitious transactions, or ineligible claims.

Common Red Flags:

Repeated Large Refunds:

• Consistent refund position without clear business model justification (exports, capital expenditure, etc.)

Supporting Documentation:

• Invoices from questionable suppliers
• Round-number invoices suggesting fabrication
• Supplier TRN invalid or deregistered

Business Model Inconsistencies:

• Refunds inconsistent with business activity
• Sudden spike in input tax without corresponding business expansion

FTA Response: Refund claims trigger enhanced scrutiny. Large or frequent refunds often trigger audit before refund is paid.

Penalties for Abusive Claims:

• Up to 50% penalty for deliberate overclaiming
• Criminal prosecution for fraudulent claims
• Permanent denial of refunds

How to Avoid Issues:

1. Ensure robust supplier verification (check TRN validity at fta.gov.ae)
2. Maintain impeccable documentation for all refund claims
3. Proactively explain business reasons for refund position
4. Conduct pre-filing review of all refund claims
5. Consider voluntary audit before filing large refund claims

Finding #8: Transfer Pricing and Related Party Transactions

The Issue: Transactions between related parties not conducted at arm's length, affecting VAT base.

Common Scenarios:

Below Market Transactions:

• Selling to related party below market value (artificially reducing output VAT)
• Purchasing from related party above market value (inflating input VAT)

Management Fees:

• Charging/receiving management fees without clear services or documentation
• Fees not aligned with value provided

Intercompany Recharges:

• Cost-plus markups without proper documentation
• Circular transactions between related parties

FTA Authority: FTA can adjust transaction values to arm's length pricing, resulting in VAT adjustments.

How to Avoid:

1. Maintain transfer pricing documentation for all related party transactions
2. Ensure services/goods billed have substance and documentation
3. Use comparable market pricing for related party transactions
4. Prepare contemporaneous documentation (not after audit notice)
5. Consider advance pricing agreement for complex structures

Finding #9: Free Zone vs. Mainland Confusion

The Issue: Incorrect VAT treatment of supplies to/from designated free zones.

Common Errors:

Designated Zone Supplies:

• Zero-rating supplies to non-designated free zones
• Standard-rating qualifying supplies to designated zones

Goods vs. Services:

• Incorrectly zero-rating services to free zones (most services are standard-rated)
• Not meeting conditions for goods zero-rating (documentation, customs clearance)

Qualifying Free Zone Person:

• Not verifying recipient is qualifying free zone person
• Assuming all free zone entities qualify (must meet specific criteria)

How to Avoid:

1. Verify free zone status using FTA designated zones list
2. Confirm customer is qualifying free zone person (obtain certificate)
3. Maintain customs documentation for all goods movements
4. Understand goods vs. services distinction for free zone supplies
5. Document basis for zero-rating at time of supply

Finding #10: E-commerce and Digital Service VAT

The Issue: Rapidly growing e-commerce and digital services often have VAT gaps.

Common Issues:

Marketplace Sales:

• Unclear who should account for VAT (platform or seller)
• Cross-border sales incorrectly treated
• Digital goods vs. physical goods confusion

Subscription Services:

• Timing of VAT on annual subscriptions
• Treatment of foreign platform subscriptions

Customer Location:

• Inadequate verification of customer location for digital services
• Assuming UAE location based on payment method

How to Avoid:

1. Understand UAE e-commerce VAT rules (marketplace deemed supplier provisions)
2. Implement robust customer location verification
3. Use automated VAT calculation for digital platforms
4. Review treatment of all digital revenue streams
5. Monitor FTA guidance on e-commerce (evolving area)

Finding #11: Capital Assets and Partial Exemption

The Issue: Incorrect treatment of VAT on capital assets when business has both taxable and exempt supplies.

Common Scenarios:

Full Input Tax Claimed:

• Claiming 100% input VAT on capital assets used for both taxable and exempt activities
• Not applying partial exemption methodology to capital expenditure

Annual Adjustment Ignored:

• Failing to conduct required annual adjustment for capital assets
• Not tracking capital assets subject to adjustment separately

Real Estate Capital Assets:

• Purchasing building for mixed use (residential rental + commercial) without proper allocation

Penalties:

• VAT assessment on incorrectly claimed input tax
• 5-50% penalties depending on circumstances

How to Avoid:

1. Implement capital asset register tracking use allocation
2. Perform annual adjustment calculations as required
3. Apply partial exemption methodology consistently
4. Document allocation basis contemporaneously
5. Review allocation methodology annually for reasonableness

Example: Company with 70% taxable / 30% exempt supplies purchased AED 525,000 (+ AED 26,250 VAT) equipment. Claimed full input tax. FTA audit required AED 7,875 (30%) repayment plus penalties.

---

Finding #12: Construction and Real Estate Specific Issues

The Issue: Unique VAT challenges in construction and real estate transactions.

Common Errors:

First Supply vs. Subsequent Supply:

• Treating second sale of residential property as exempt (only first supply exempt)
• Confusion over what constitutes "first supply"

Land vs. Building:

• Incorrect treatment of bare land sales
• Mixed supplies of land + building not properly separated

Building Conversion:

• Converting commercial to residential (or reverse) without proper VAT treatment
• Not accounting for deemed supply on conversion

Construction Services:

• Subcontractor payments not properly tracked for reverse charge
• Retention amounts and VAT timing errors

Penalties: Real estate errors often involve large amounts: AED 50K-500K+ assessments common

How to Avoid:

1. Obtain specialist real estate VAT advice for complex transactions
2. Document property history to determine first/subsequent supply
3. Review all property transactions for correct classification
4. Maintain detailed records of building conversions
5. Implement controls for construction subcontractor VAT

---

Finding #13: Import VAT and Customs Declarations

The Issue: Errors in accounting for import VAT and reverse charge mechanisms.

Common Scenarios:

Postponed VAT Account Issues:

• Not properly accounting for both output and input VAT on same return
• Failing to maintain separate postponed VAT accounting
• Mixing postponed VAT with standard input tax

Custom Valuation Errors:

• Using incorrect customs value for VAT calculation
• Not including freight, insurance in VAT base
• Currency conversion errors

Temporary Imports:

• Not accounting for VAT on temporary imports
• Incorrect re-export treatment

GCC Imports:

• Not applying reverse charge on imports from other GCC states
• Missing customs documentation for GCC movements

How to Avoid:

1. Reconcile customs declarations to VAT returns monthly
2. Implement separate tracking for postponed VAT account
3. Train import/logistics team on VAT implications
4. Review customs valuation methodology
5. Maintain all customs clearance documentation

---

Case Study: Multi-Finding FTA Audit Resolution

Company Profile:

• Industry: Trading and distribution
• Annual Revenue: AED 65M
• VAT-registered since 2018
• Years Audited: 2020-2023

Audit Trigger: Refund claim of AED 185,000 in Q4 2023

FTA Findings:

Finding #1: Input Tax Overclaimed (AED 142,000)

• Personal use of company vehicles not excluded
• Entertainment expenses claimed without business purpose
• Mixed-use office space (30% residential use) not allocated

Finding #2: Documentation Issues (68 invoices)

• 42 invoices missing valid TRN
• 26 invoices with incomplete VAT information
• Penalties: AED 340,000 (AED 5,000 × 68)

Finding #3: Place of Supply Errors (AED 86,000 output VAT underpaid)

• Services to GCC clients treated as zero-rated instead of standard-rated
• Insufficient evidence of customer location for 18 transactions

Finding #4: Timing Errors

• AED 45,000 advance payments not accounted for in correct period
• Late payment penalties: AED 2,700

Total Assessment:

• VAT underpaid: AED 228,000 (output shortfall + input overclaimed)
• Administrative penalties: AED 340,000 (invalid invoices)
• Late payment penalties: AED 2,700
• Tax-related penalties: AED 45,600 (20% of tax error)
• TOTAL: AED 616,300

Our Intervention:

Step 1: Immediate Damage Control

• Prepared comprehensive voluntary disclosure for timing errors (discovered mid-audit)
• Secured penalty reduction from 50% to 20% through cooperation

Step 2: Documentation Appeal

• Obtained corrected invoices from 38 of 68 suppliers
• Demonstrated genuine business transactions despite invoice defects
• Negotiated penalty reduction for 38 invoices: From AED 190,000 to AED 38,000

Step 3: Substantive Arguments

• Provided additional evidence for place of supply determinations
• Reduced assessment from AED 86,000 to AED 38,000 (58 transactions upheld, reduced assessment)
• Challenged vehicle allocation methodology with detailed mileage logs
• Reduced personal use assessment from 40% to 25%

Step 4: Settlement Negotiation

• Proposed payment plan for agreed amounts
• Demonstrated financial hardship from full immediate payment
• Agreed installment plan over 12 months

Final Settlement:

• VAT assessment: AED 166,000 (27% reduction from initial)
• Administrative penalties: AED 150,000 (56% reduction)
• Tax-related penalties: AED 33,200 (27% reduction)
• TOTAL: AED 349,200 (43% reduction from AED 616,300)

Lessons:

1. Documentation is critical – 56% of penalties related to invoice issues
2. Proactive voluntary disclosure mid-audit reduced penalties
3. Specialist representation achieved 43% reduction in total assessment
4. Payment plan prevented business cash flow crisis

Quote from CFO: "We thought we were VAT compliant. The AED 616K assessment was devastating. Farahat & Co's expertise in negotiating with FTA and presenting our case saved us AED 267K and prevented business disruption from immediate payment demands."

---

Proactive VAT Compliance Strategies

1. Internal VAT Health Checks (Quarterly)

Conduct internal reviews covering:

• Sample testing of input tax claims (20-30 transactions)
• Output tax calculation verification
• Invoice compliance spot checks (50-100 invoices)
• Timing verification (month-end cutoffs)
• Place of supply reviews (international transactions)

Quarterly Checklist: ☐ Review 25 largest input tax claims for eligibility ☐ Verify 50 random invoices for compliance ☐ Test place of supply for all international sales ☐ Reconcile VAT returns to accounting system ☐ Review any refund positions for supportability

2. Annual VAT Review

Engage external advisor for comprehensive annual review before potential FTA audit.

Annual Review Scope:

• Comprehensive testing of high-risk areas
• Review of all voluntary disclosures made
• Assessment of VAT system adequacy
• Benchmarking of VAT ratios vs. industry
• Preparation of audit defense file

Cost vs. Benefit:

• Annual review cost: AED 15,000-35,000
• Average penalty savings: AED 50,000-150,000
• ROI: Typically 200-400%

3. VAT Training

Regular training for:

• Finance team (comprehensive, semi-annual)
• Sales team (invoicing, place of supply, annual)
• Procurement (input tax recovery, annual)
• IT team (e-commerce, system controls, annual)

4. VAT Technology

Implement systems to:

• Automate VAT calculations
• Flag non-compliant invoices at receipt
• Generate VAT reports for review
• Maintain audit trail
• Alert on unusual transactions

Technology ROI:

• System cost: AED 20,000-80,000 (one-time + annual subscription)
• Staff time savings: 20-40 hours/month
• Error reduction: 60-80%
• Penalty avoidance: AED 30,000-100,000 annually

5. Documentation Culture

Create organizational culture prioritizing:

• Contemporaneous documentation
• Clear business purpose on all transactions
• Audit-ready record keeping
• Proactive error identification and disclosure

---

What to Do If FTA Audit Notification Received

Immediate Actions (Day 1-3):

1. Don't Panic: Audits are common and don't necessarily indicate suspicion of fraud
2. Notify Key Stakeholders: Inform management, board, finance team
3. Engage Advisor: Consider engaging VAT specialist for audit support (critical within 3 days)
4. Document Preservation: Ensure no records altered or destroyed

Preparation Phase (Week 1-2): 4. Gather Records: Organize all requested documentation systematically 5. Conduct Pre-Audit Review: Identify potential issues before FTA finds them 6. Consider Voluntary Disclosure: If significant errors found, disclose immediately before audit begins 7. Prepare Team: Designate single point of contact, brief all staff who may be interviewed

During Audit (Weeks 3-8): 8. Be Cooperative: Professional, timely responses improve audit experience and outcomes 9. Document Everything: Keep records of all audit communications, meetings, document requests 10. Controlled Information Flow: All responses reviewed by advisor before submission 11. Understand Findings: Request detailed explanations of any findings before accepting

Post-Audit (Weeks 9-12): 12. Review Assessment: Carefully analyze audit report and assessment basis 13. Consider Objection: File objection if disagree with findings (20-day deadline) 14. Negotiate Settlement: Discuss payment plans if assessment is large 15. Implement Remediation: Fix identified issues to prevent recurrence

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How likely is my business to be audited by FTA?

Answer: Audit probability varies by risk factors:

High Risk (30-50% chance within 3 years):

• Frequent refund claims
• Significant VAT errors in past returns
• Industry with known compliance issues (construction, gold trading)
• Revenue > AED 100M

Medium Risk (10-20% chance):

• Occasional refunds
• Standard business operations
• Revenue AED 10-100M

Low Risk (< 5% chance):

• Consistent net VAT payable
• Small business (< AED 10M revenue)
• No unusual patterns

Audit Triggers:

• Refund claims (especially first refund or large amounts)
• VAT return anomalies (sudden changes, unusual ratios)
• Third-party information (supplier audits, customs data)
• Industry-specific campaigns
• Random selection

Bottom Line: All VAT-registered businesses should assume audit is possible and maintain audit-ready compliance.

---

2. Can penalties be reduced or waived?

Answer: Yes—penalties can often be reduced significantly:

Penalty Reduction Opportunities:

Voluntary Disclosure (Before Audit):

• Standard penalty: 50% of tax
• Voluntary disclosure penalty: 5% of tax
• Reduction: 90%

Cooperation During Audit:

• Full cooperation can reduce penalties from 50% to 30-20%
• Providing requested information promptly
• Professional, respectful interactions

First-Time Offenders:

• FTA may show leniency for genuine errors
• Good compliance history helps

Financial Hardship:

• Payment plans available (doesn't reduce amount but spreads payments)
• In rare cases, penalties reduced due to demonstrated hardship

Technical Complexity:

• Penalties may be reduced if issue was genuinely complex/unclear
• Must demonstrate reasonable interpretation attempt

Example Outcomes:

• Case 1: AED 150K penalty reduced to AED 30K through voluntary disclosure
• Case 2: AED 80K penalty reduced to AED 48K through full cooperation
• Case 3: AED 200K penalty maintained at 50% due to deliberate non-compliance

Key: Early specialist advice maximizes penalty reduction opportunities.

---

3. What happens if I can't pay the VAT assessment immediately?

Answer: Payment plan options are available:

Immediate Payment Discount:

• Pay within 20 business days: May negotiate small discount (5-10% on penalties)

Installment Plans:

• FTA offers payment plans for large assessments
• Typical terms: 6-24 months depending on amount
• Interest/late payment penalties continue to accrue
• Requires financial disclosure and security in some cases

Typical Installment Terms:

• Assessment < AED 100K: 6-12 months
• Assessment AED 100K-500K: 12-18 months
• Assessment > AED 500K: 18-24 months

Requirements for Approval:

• Demonstrated inability to pay immediately
• Financial statements/projections
• Proposed payment schedule
• Possibly personal guarantee or security

Alternative: Objection

• Filing objection (within 20 days) can suspend payment requirement pending resolution
• But must have genuine grounds for objection
• Frivolous objections damage credibility

Example: Company with AED 380K assessment:

• Immediate payment: Cash flow crisis, potential insolvency
• Negotiated: AED 25,000/month for 15 months
• Total paid: AED 405K (AED 25K in additional late payment penalties)
• Business survived, compliance maintained

---

4. How far back can FTA audit?

Answer: Standard period: 5 years from end of relevant tax period

Calculation:

• Tax period: January 2020
• Audit can occur until: January 31, 2026

Extended Period (20 years): FTA can extend to 20 years if:

• Tax evasion suspected
• Deliberate fraud
• False returns filed

Practical Reality:

• Most audits cover 3-4 years (balance of detail vs. resources)
• Refund claim audits: Typically 1-2 years
• Comprehensive audits: 3-5 years

Record Retention Requirement: Must maintain all VAT records for minimum 5 years

Implications:

• Don't destroy records for 5+ years
• Errors older than 5 years generally cannot be assessed (unless fraud)
• Voluntary disclosures should cover all open periods (5 years)

---

5. Should I engage a VAT advisor if I receive an audit notice?

Answer: Strongly recommended in most cases:

When Specialist Advisor is Critical: Large potential assessment (> AED 50K) Complex technical issues Multiple findings across different areas Refund claim audit (high scrutiny) First audit (no prior experience) Potential penalties > AED 20K

When You Might Handle Internally:

• Small, straightforward audit
• Single, clear issue
• Experienced internal tax team
• Low financial exposure

Advisor Value:

Technical Expertise:

• Understanding VAT law nuances
• Presenting legal arguments effectively
• Knowing FTA procedures and personnel

Penalty Reduction:

• Average reduction: 30-60% through negotiation
• Voluntary disclosure strategy
• Settlement negotiation

Time Savings:

• Internal team focuses on business
• Advisor handles FTA coordination
• Faster resolution

Cost vs. Benefit:

• Advisor cost: AED 15,000-50,000 (depending on complexity)
• Typical penalty savings: AED 50,000-200,000
• ROI: Usually 200-500%

Example:

• DIY approach: AED 285K assessment, full penalties
• With advisor: AED 178K final settlement
• Advisor cost: AED 28K
• Net savings: AED 79K

---

6. What are the most important documents to maintain for VAT audit?

Answer: Essential VAT audit documentation:

Priority 1 (Critical - Must Have):

1. Tax Invoices: All supplier invoices with valid TRN, VAT breakdown
2. Sales Invoices: All issued invoices matching VAT return
3. VAT Returns: All filed returns with supporting calculations
4. Bank Statements: Showing all business transactions
5. General Ledger: Complete accounting records

Priority 2 (Very Important): 6. Contracts: Customer/supplier agreements showing VAT terms 7. Import/Export Documents: Customs declarations, bills of lading 8. Credit Notes: All issued and received with proper documentation 9. Payment Evidence: Proof of payment for input tax claims 10. Reconciliations: VAT return to accounts reconciliation

Priority 3 (Supporting Documentation): 11. Place of Supply Evidence: Customer location proof (address, delivery location) 12. Exemption/Zero-Rating Support: Documentation of qualifying conditions 13. Allocation Methodologies: For partial exemption, mixed use assets 14. Board Minutes: Approving significant transactions 15. Correspondence: Any FTA queries/responses

Organization System:

• Folder by tax period
• Subfolders: Sales, Purchases, Returns, Reconciliations, Correspondence
• Digital preferred (searchable, backed up)
• Retention: Minimum 5 years

Red Flags to Avoid: Missing invoices from key suppliers Handwritten invoices without backup Email confirmations instead of tax invoices Gaps in invoice numbering sequence Invoices created/modified after transactions

---

Conclusion

VAT compliance in the UAE requires diligent attention to detail, robust systems, and proactive management. The most common findings—from input tax errors to documentation deficiencies—are preventable with proper controls, training, and regular reviews.

Key Takeaways:

1. Prevention is cheaper than cure: Proactive compliance review (AED 15K-35K) vs. average audit penalties (AED 50K-300K)
2. Documentation is critical: 40-60% of penalties relate to inadequate documentation
3. Specialist advice pays off: Professional representation typically achieves 30-60% penalty reduction
4. Voluntary disclosure works: 90% penalty reduction for proactive error correction
5. Technology helps: Automated systems reduce errors by 60-80%

Action Plan: ☐ Conduct internal VAT health check quarterly ☐ Engage advisor for annual comprehensive review ☐ Implement robust documentation procedures ☐ Train all staff touching VAT transactions ☐ Consider VAT automation technology ☐ Maintain audit-ready records at all times

At Farahat & Co, we provide comprehensive VAT services including:

• VAT Compliance Reviews: Proactive identification of issues (AED 15,000-35,000)
• FTA Audit Support: Expert representation during audits
• Voluntary Disclosure Preparation: Penalty minimization strategies
• VAT System Implementation: Technology and process optimization
• Training and Advisory: Building internal VAT competence

Our Track Record:

• 340+ FTA audits supported
• Average penalty reduction: 47%
• 94% of voluntary disclosures accepted by FTA
• Zero clients received maximum penalties

Don't wait for an FTA audit to discover VAT issues. Proactive review and correction is far less costly than penalties.

Contact us for a confidential VAT compliance assessment: [Request Assessment] | Call: +971-X-XXX-XXXX | Email: vat@farahatco.com

---

Related Resources

• VAT Compliance Guide 2025 - Complete VAT compliance framework
• VAT Audit Services - Professional FTA audit support
• UAE Audit Requirements 2025 - Statutory audit obligations